Express True Crime Tour

Duration: 75 Minutes*

Take a journey through time as we visit the key locations tied to some of Indianapolis's most infamous criminal cases. This tour uncovers the haunting stories of cult leaders, serial killers, unsolved mysteries, and historic tragedies that have left their mark on the city.

Tour Highlights Include:

  • Herb Baumeister - Visit where Herb would target his victims

  • John Dillinger’s First Robbery – Step back into the origin of his criminal career

  • Rev. Jim Jones – See where the cult leader of Jonestown spent his early years

*Exact tour locations are subject to change based on timing and availability.

👉 BOOK THE Express TRUE CRIME TOUR

 
 
 

Drive & Dive Tour

Duration: 120 Minutes*

Want more than a quick crime fix but not quite ready for the full deep-dive experience? The True Crime Drive & Dive Tour is your perfect middle ground.

This 2-hour thrill ride through Indianapolis crime history offers a blend of chilling storytelling, compelling visuals, and two immersive photo stops where infamous events once unfolded. From notorious gangster getaways to shocking scenes of murder and mayhem, you’ll hear it all while riding in comfort—and step out twice to stand where history happened.

Our expert guide will lead you through:

  • Legendary tales of John Dillinger, America’s most wanted

  • The chilling murder that exposed the dark heart of the KKK’s D.C. Stephenson

  • A stop at a real crime scene tied to a headline-grabbing case

  • The eerie details of Herb Baumeister, the family man turned suspected serial killer

  • Plus shocking cases and unsolved mysteries that still echo through Indy’s streets

It’s the perfect dose of darkness—with time to capture it on camera.

What’s Included:

  • 2-hour narrated bus tour led by a true crime expert

  • 2 photo-worthy stops at historic crime scenes

  • Dark, disturbing, and totally unforgettable stories

  • The right mix of info, interaction, and intrigue

Ideal For:

  • Guests who want more than a drive-by

  • Locals and tourists with a taste for eerie history

  • Those who want to snap some spooky pics for social media

  • Crime buffs craving Indy’s greatest hits—without the full commitment

👉 BOOK THE Drive and Dive Tour

Exclusive “PRIME CRIME” TOURS

 

Looking for the ultimate true crime and history experience? Our Premium Level Tours are the deluxe version of our tours, combining exclusive access, expert-led commentary, and a touch of indulgence for the ultimate fan of true crime and dark history.

What’s Included:

  • Start at Barringer’s Tavern – Enjoy complimentary food and drinks as you meet your guide and fellow tour-goers. Try Al Capone’s Favorite drink while you sit in a spot he allegedly visited.

  • Crown Hill Cemetery – Step out of the vehicle for a guided walk to Dillinger’s grave and learn about the cemetery’s storied past

  • Rev. Jim Jones’ Church Site – Explore the spot where his disturbing path began

  • Infamous Location Exploration – Exclusive access to one of Indy’s most Infamous locations

  • Slippery Noodle Inn – Unwind with drinks at this legendary Prohibition-era bar

  • Exclusive Souvenir T-Shirt – Take home a stylish keepsake commemorating your journey into Indy’s criminal past

  • Guest Speakers – Selected tours include appearances by local historians, authors, or retired law enforcement officers offering unique insights

Note: Premium experiences are sometimes offered twice per month (maybe more maybe less) and require advance booking. Group sizes are limited to ensure an intimate and immersive experience.

👉 GET NOTIFIED ABOUT PRIME CRIME TOUR



 

Infamous Haunts & Horrors

Ghosts. Grit. And the gruesome truth.

This October, climb aboard for Infamous Haunts & Horrors—a chilling blend of Indy’s most haunted legends and its darkest true crime history. From shadowy alleyways to sites of real-life horror, this tour uncovers the eerie overlap between the city’s restless spirits and the blood-curdling crimes that may have summoned them.

Led by a former investigative reporter and award-winning true crime podcaster, you’ll hear shocking stories of murder, mystery, and the supernatural that mainstream history leaves buried.

** Exclusive Infamous Indy Halloween Gift included

What You’ll Experience:

  • A 2-hour immersive nighttime bus tour

  • Stops at infamous locations linked to both hauntings and historic crimes

  • Real stories of Indy’s murderers, mobsters, and the ghosts they may have left behind

  • Spine-tingling facts, atmospheric storytelling, and a few eerie surprises along the way

🎃 Only available during the Halloween season. Limited dates. Limited seats.

Dare to ride? Book your seat before it disappears into the night.

👉 Book Halloween Tour






Private Group Tours & Exclusive CRIME Experiences

 

Want a Tour All to Yourself? We've Got You Covered.

Infamous Indy Tours proudly offers private group tours for those who want a more personal, tailored experience. Whether you're planning a corporate outing, private event, team-building activity, birthday party, bachelor/bachelorette night, or just a unique evening with friends, our private tours bring true crime and Indy history to life, just for you.

You’ll get:

  • A dedicated guide (often Joe Melillo himself)

  • Flexible scheduling to fit your needs

  • Custom route options based on your group's interests

  • Insider stories not told on our public tours

Private tours start at a flat group rate and are available upon request.

👉 Inquire About a Private Tours